Jack's Pizza - Indianapolis: A Slice of Tradition and Flavor
Jack's Pizza in Indianapolis has been a beloved staple since the early 1970s, known for its richly topped pizzas bursting with flavor. Located at 5650 E 86th St, this carry-out-only establishment specializes in classic favorites like their ex-large sausage and mushroom pizza, which keeps customers coming back for more. The generous toppings and signature oregano set Jack's apart from the competition. Patrons rave about the quick service and nostalgic quality, with many claiming it as their longtime favorite. Each visit promises a delectable experience, making Jack's Pizza a must-try for both locals and visitors alike.
Photos & Gallery
Popular Menu Items
Sausage and Mushroom Pizza
Sausage Pizza Slice
Big Jack Pizza
Chicken Wings
Sausage Pepperoni Ham
1 2 Sausage 1 2 Cheese Pizza
Jack's Pizza - Indianapolis: Reviews & Ratings
Just stoped by today, picked up an ex-large sausage and mushroom pizza. The wife and I have been eating Jacks Pizza for a very long time. We just love Jacks and have been loyal customers since the early 1970’s. All their pizzas come with oregano so if you don’t go for that tell them to leave it off. There is no indoor seating, carry out only.
Reality rarely exceeds my expectations, but wow! Ordered around 4:45ish pm crew was lively, communicated well, and delivered one of the most top-notch pizzas we have had. 14” Big Jack (Supreme) totaled about $30. Well worth the splurge! Walked in to order and left with our dinner within 20 mins! Only thing that could have improved our experience would be seats (:
I have been having Jack's Pizza for over 40 years. And it is still my absolute favorite! The Castleton is my go to location They make it the same way with lots of toppings and delicious taste every time! Hey Papa John's, ever heard of putting toppings on your pizza instead of it just being mainly sauce? Everybody should treat themselves just once and try Jacks. You won't regret it!
My all time favorite pizza. Been getting their sausage since I was a kid. Now pick up a pie each time I’m through Indy. The guy who checked me out threw on a coupon and saved me some money. I just added that to his tip as that was great service. I do wish they’d ship frozen ones.
Fantastic pizza! Ordered it both nights of my stay. Delivered straight to my room
First time trying this pizza. Sauce was a little too spicy (hot) for us. If you like pizza with a little kick, you'll probably like this. Crust and breadsticks were okay. Pretty dense and heavy. Cheese and toppings were very good. Wasn't bad but also wasn't what we prefer, which is more New York style if that helps with comparison to your tastes. Service was good. Ready when stated. Appreciated the friendliness of staff member.
Finally made it to Jack's, and it didn't disappoint. If you are a toppings person, this is your spot. Thin crust, tavern style, and piled high. Their version of a supreme is fantastically fresh and loaded. We also got an 18in half pepperoni half cheese which was solid. I would stay away from this place if you are a one topping pizza lover. The bang is in the loaded specialty pizzas. We'll be back for those.
Location
-
5650 E 86th St, Indianapolis, IN 46250, United States Hotline: +1 317-841-1966
Welcome to Jack's Pizza - Indianapolis, a beloved gem nestled at 5650 E 86th St, Indianapolis, IN 46250. This iconic pizzeria has been delighting taste buds for decades, and its reputation as a go-to destination for pizza lovers is well earned. With no indoor seating available, Jack's Pizza embraces a cozy carry-out model that allows customers to enjoy their scrumptious creations in the comfort of their own homes.
The heart of Jack's irresistible charm lies in its dedication to quality and tradition. Customers like The Dining Grandpa and David Brumbaugh have been loyal fans for more than 40 years, savoring exquisite combinations like the humble sausage and mushroom and their top-tier supreme variety, aptly named the 14” Big Jack. Reviews reflect a consistent theme: the toppings are generous and fresh while the flavor is undeniably memorable.
With a warm and lively crew, the spirit of camaraderie extends beyond the kitchen to the counter. As Kristina Beers experienced, prompt service is paramount, with pizzas often ready in about 20 minutes. It’s not just about grabbing a meal; it’s about enjoying a slice of the community that calls Jack's Pizza its own.
The signature oregano sprinkled on each pie has become a hallmark of the brand, giving every bite a distinct flavor. And for those who prefer a different touch, simply ask to leave it off. Jack’s is a pizzeria that honors its roots while constantly pleasing its patrons, as noted by customers who have shared thoughtful encounters with staff who go the extra mile to enhance their experience.
Whether you’re a lifelong fan or a first-timer craving a delightful slice, Jack's Pizza is a delicious reminder of what makes pizza special. It's more than just a meal; it’s an experience—a legacy of taste and warmth that invites everyone to relish each bite. As Don Storer aptly put it, "My all-time favorite pizza." With such heartfelt endorsements, one can only leave intrigued and eager to partake in the joyous flavors that await. So, don’t miss out—pick up your next pie from Jack’s and indulge in a taste of Indianapolis history!
- Accessibility
- Wheelchair-accessible car park
- Wheelchair-accessible entrance
- Service options
- Delivery
- Takeaway
- Dine-in
- Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards